Lately, I
have been getting a lot of questions about target date funds. No wonder. Target
date funds are being touted as the answer to our retirement investing
conundrum. They are being proposed as the default choice in a 401(k) plan. And
they are sprouting up like weeds. So should you put your money in a target date
fund?
The short
answer is ... only as a last resort. But first things first.
A target date
fund is a mutual fund with an asset allocation tied to your target retirement
date. If you think you will retire in 20 years, you would pick a 2030 target
date fund, with 2030 being roughly the year you plan to retire.
These funds
are really funds of funds. The fund manager chooses other funds, from the same
fund family, in percentages that make up a reasonable asset allocation given
your time until retirement. It is the fund managers job to adjust those
percentages for you automatically as your retirement date approaches, becoming
progressively more conservative. These funds typically hold a mix of stocks,
bonds and cash and will often include an allocation to foreign equities as
well.
It's no
wonder I have been getting so many questions about target date funds lately. In
2000, there were only 23 target date funds in existence, with just about $8
billion in assets. Today, there are over 250 target date funds, with $160
billion in assets, and more being brought to market every day. But should you
plunk your retirement savings in a target date fund and forget it?
I don't think
so and here is why …
1. One size
doesn't fit all, with any investment.
2. Target
date funds are too conservative.
3. There are
better ways.
Target date
funds are being touted as one stop shopping. Just pick a retirement date, pick
the fund with your retirement year in the name, and let the fund manager do the
rest. But does it really make sense that the CEO of a company should have the
same asset allocation as a clerk in his Accounting Department? Not likely!
An investor
has to put together an asset allocation based on his or her long-term
objectives, risk tolerance, time horizon and temperament. You choose the
combination of investments that has the highest probability of satisfying each
of those criteria over your anticipated time horizon. It is possible that is a
single investment but often it is not.
My biggest
gripe with target date funds is they are too conservative. Let's make some
assumptions about your retirement. The first is your retirement will last
thirty years. That is the joint life expectancy of a 65 year old, non-smoking
couple.
Second is
that inflation will average 3.5% over that 30 years. Forget for a moment that
seniors experience inflation at a greater rate than the nation as a whole,
largely because of the cost of healthcare. We'll just use the historical
average.
Third is that
you will begin withdrawing funds from your portfolio at the rate of 4% a year.
And fourth, let's assume your marginal tax bracket will be 25%. Now, what is
the return required over your 30 years in retirement to pay Uncle Sam, pay you,
and still get enough growth in your portfolio to keep up with inflation?
The answer is
10%. That is (4 + 3.5) / (1-.25) or your withdrawal rate plus inflation divided
by one minus your marginal tax rate. Which means we have a gap. Our current way
of thinking about investments is too conservative.
If you model
the traditional 60%/40% retirement portfolio, the expected rate of return over
30 years is only 8%. A 4% withdrawal rate may give me a high probability I
won't run out of money but it almost assures that I won't be able to buy
anything with the money I have left. In order to protect against conversion
risk, target date funds, because they are based on asset allocation models
designed for our parents and grandparents, get too conservative too fast.
What worked
for previous generations will not work for ours. We are the first generation
solely responsible for funding our own retirement. Unfortunately, no one told
us that until, for many of us, it was too late. On top of that, we are living
longer. Life expectancy has increased by ten years. That is both good news and
bad news. That's ten more years to travel, play golf and spend quality time
with our family. But it is also ten more years without a paycheck.
Like it or
not, we have to come to grips with the idea that our investment time horizon
isn't our retirement date. Our time horizon extends over our entire lifetime.
Moreover, it seems plainly obvious to me our lifestyle in retirement is going
to be a function the amount of our portfolio we leave in stocks. Unless you are
one of the few with more than enough money, that is the only way our portfolio
can keep up with inflation, taxes, and still support a reasonable lifestyle
over 30 years.
Target date
funds don't do that. They are by nature too conservative.
My regular
readers and radio show listeners know I don't like mutual funds, as a rule. I
especially don't like actively managed mutual funds because their high fees
guarantee over time you will under-perform the market itself. The only time I
would ever use a mutual fund is in an employer-sponsored retirement account,
like a 401(k) or 403(b) and that is just because I don't have a choice.
Most plans
are adding target date funds as an investment option. Should you choose it?
Only as a
last resort. I believe a well-thought out asset allocation of low-cost index
funds, like the one in our 401(k) course,
is the much better plan. But if your plan doesn't offer low-cost index funds,
or you aren't willing to spend the time and money required to learn how to
maximize your 401(k), (which is minimal BTW), then target date funds are far
better than just picking the funds with the best historical performance and/or
allocating between stocks and bonds based on what you think the market is going
to do. That is a sure fire way to waste your retirement funds.
Bottom line
on target date funds … they aren't the panacea the fund industry would like us
to think they are. Do the work. You can do better.
Kim Snider Financial Communications makes no representation that the
information and opinions expressed are accurate, complete or current. The
opinions expressed should not be construed as financial, legal, tax, or other
advice and are provided for informational purposes only. Call 866-952-0100 to
request the Snider
Investment Method™ Owner's Manual, which includes a description of the
Snider Investment Method, investment objectives, risks, suitability and other
information. Please read and consider carefully before investing. All
investments are subject to risk, including possible loss of principal.
Individual results may vary. Individual performance depends on individual
savings, investment time frame and market conditions. Diversification does not
ensure a profit or protect against loss in a declining market.